A: Many years ago, early in my walk with the Lord, I felt like it would be a good idea in my personal prayer time to personalize the Lord’s Prayer, saying: “My Father… give me this day, my daily bread, and forgive me my trespasses..,” rather than praying the traditional “Our Father….” However, as I did this in the weeks that followed, something felt wrong. I can’t explain it, but I felt conviction inside of me that the Lord did not want me praying that way. I stopped, without giving it a second thought.
Well today, this subject has come up again, and I “am” giving it a second thought. Is it “actually” wrong to pray “My Father,” rather than “Our Father?” While I don’t usually go this route, as I studied this subject, some of who I consider to be the best “old time” scholars had some interesting things to say on this. Therefore, I am primarily going to quote them.
The first is from “G Campbell Morgan D.D.” in “The Gospel According to Matthew.”
“Then observe the socialism, the communism of the prayer. We must use a strong word because it is a strong prayer. Notice the pronouns of the prayer, the pronouns in the first person; “Our – us – our – us- our -we – our – us – us.” There is not a pronoun in the first person singular. They are all plural. There is no room for selfishness there. We are bound to bring somebody else in with us… He (Jesus) says, “Enter into thine inner chamber, and… shut thy door,” and when nobody is there but yourself, begin to pray as though the whole world were with you. That is Christ’s socialism.”
The second is from “John Gill” in his commentary.
“…inasmuch as the direction is not to say “my Father,” but “our Father;” it shows that we should pray for others as well as for ourselves, even for all the dear children of God. It is a rule with the Jews, “that a man ought always to join himself in prayer with the church; “upon which the gloss says, “let him not pray the short prayer, in the singular, but in the plural number, so that his prayer may be heard.”
The third is from “Adam Clarke” in “Clarke’s Commentary.”
It was a maxim of the Jews, that a man should not pray alone, but join with the Church; by which they particularly meant that he should, whether alone or with the synagogue, use the plural as comprehending all the followers of God. Hence, they say, Let none pray the short prayer, i.e. as the gloss expounds it, the prayer in the singular, but in the plural number. This prayer was evidently made in a peculiar manner for the children of God. And hence we are taught to say, not MY Father, but OUR Father, The heart, says one, of a child of God, is a brotherly heart, in respect of all other Christians: it asks nothing but in the spirit of unity, fellowship, and Christian charity; desiring that for its brethren which it desires for itself.”
***Note: Charles Spurgeon also has a similar, longer explanation in: “Spurgeon’s Verse Expositions of the Bible: The Fatherhood of God” (9-12-1858).
Of course, the “views” of classic Bible scholars are not equal to what the Bible actually says. In this vain, I believe two things are worth considering.
The first is reading what precedes the Lord’s Prayer in (Mt 6:5-9). When we look at the use of “you” and “your” in (Mt 6:5,7,8,9), we see that they are “second person plural.” In other words, it would be like one who speaks to a crowd and says, “You need to believe me when I say this.” The “you” means everyone in the audience. So, in (Mt 5:5), we have Jesus saying, “And when you (everyone in the audience) pray, you (everyone one in the audience) shall not be like the hypocrites.” However, in (Mt 6:6), the “you” and “your” that Jesus uses changes to “second person singular.” This is the verse that says (NKJV), “But you, when you pray, go into your room (the KJV uses “closet,” and I like this), and when you have shut your door, pray to your Father who is in the secret place; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly.”
In other words, Jesus is saying: “But you (individually), when you pray (individually), go into your (personal) prayer closet, shut the door, and pray to your Father… and He will reward you (personally) openly.” Jesus then goes back to the plural in (Mt 6:7), and says, “when you (everyone in the audience) pray (in your closet), do not use vain repetitions,” but instead (Mt 6:9), “pray in this manner.”
He then gives those individuals “praying in the closet with the door shut” the Lord’s Prayer. He doesn’t use “singular pronouns” in this prayer, but “plural” pronouns. He doesn’t tell the individual to pray “My Father… give me this day my daily bread, and forgive me my trespasses…” Obviously, this is not by accident. Doesn’t it seem logical to conclude that Jesus wanted “singular” people to pray for the “plural” people (fellow believers = the “church”) (they themselves included in that)?
Secondly, it is worth noting the prayers of great men and women throughout the Bible. Jesus’ prayer in (Jn Ch. 17), and numerous other prayers (i.e. Ex 32:11-14, 1 Sam 2:1-10, Lk 1:46-55, Eph 3:14-21, Col 1:9-14) were constantly prayers of praise and worship to the Lord, and intercession for others. They rarely focused their prayers on themselves. Keeping this in mind, this clearly fits well with the Lord’s Prayer. Jesus asking us to intercede on behalf of our brothers and sisters in Christ from every “nation, tribe, people, and tongue,” and uniting with them as they also pray this prayer.
Ultimately however, since the Bible does not “clearly” say that it is wrong to “personalize” the Lord’s Prayer, this is a matter between each person, and the Lord. Pray, and ask Him to reveal His will in this matter.
—–
Before I close, let me add three important things related to this.
First, the Lord’s Prayer is mentioned two “separate” times in the Gospels. The prayer we have focused on here in Matthew (Mt 6:9-13) was at the beginning of Jesus’ ministry, and another mention in (Lk 11:1-4) was near the end of His ministry.
Second, the “Lord’s Prayer” is prayed to God the “Father.” God is “not” the Father of all people. All people were created by God, and made in His image (Gen 1:26)(Gen 9:6)(James 3:8-9), however, not all people are “children of God.” The Bible tells us that we are “children of God by faith in Christ Jesus” (Gal 3:26)(Jn 1:12)(Rom 8:14-17). Once we have accepted Jesus Christ as our Lord and Savior, we are “born to a new life” (Jn 3:3-8), “adopted” (Eph 1:5-6)(Rom 8:15)(Gal 4:5-6) into the family of God. God the Father becomes “Our Father.” Until you become a “child of God,” you cannot pray this prayer, either for yourself, or in unity with other believers around the world (see: Does God hear a non-Christians prayer?). To accept Jesus as your Lord and Savior, and make God the Father “your” Father, please go here.
Third, it is worth noting that in the verses leading up to the Lord’s Prayer, Jesus focused on “not” using “vain repetitions” when praying (Mt 6:7). He then gave this prayer as “guideline” of how to avoid vain repetition. Unfortunately, many churches have turned the Lord’s Prayer itself into a “vain repetition” by praying it over and over. I grew up in a church like this. Please do not make the same mistake that I did, by mindlessly mouthing the words of this prayer with no forethought or heart.
Copyright: https://JesusAlive.cc © Steve Shirley
More Questions & Answers